Starter Theory Order

Starter Theory

Sourdough and gluten-free cookies, baked to order every week in SWFL.

Theory: good bread starts with a good starter.

Ours is flour and water, fed every day.

When it has doubled, it's ready.

We shape it, score it and bake it.

Proof: this is what comes out.

Who's baking

Matthew + Jessica

Starter Theory began as a hobby in our home kitchen. It grew one loaf and one batch at a time, until it needed a name.

Someone at our table eats gluten-free, so the cookies have been gluten-free from the start. The sourdough is the traditional kind, made with wheat flour.

We both bake. Every order is made by the two of us in the week you order it, so nothing sits on a shelf waiting.

How ordering works

  1. Order by Choose your loaves and cookies before orders close for the week.
  2. We bake on We mix, ferment and bake everything to order. Nothing is made ahead.
  3. Pick it up